Notice how you can't find any 5.5s, but 4.5s are plentiful? That is because the 5.5" Sport Beetle wheels are RARE![/size]
Rare parts cost more than common parts.
well put. that's what i was going to say.
that and the fact that gary is a straight shooter (so you dont have to worry about a shifty seller), he's local (so you dont have to worry about shipping & recieving & all the crap that goes along with it), and they are available right now (so you dont need to spend anymore time on the www searching for wheels + all the time it takes for email correspondence & all that).
that makes it a great deal!!!
imho, i would get the cash and buy gary's 5.5's, mount your 205's to those and run your 4.5's up front and have a killer set of wheels for your bug. i am a firm believer that the wheel & tire combo on a car has alot to do with it's overall appearance. it can make or break "the look".
and dont run 205's on 4.5" rims. that size tire is far to wide for that rim.
good luck ches. B)