Your rear tires are way toooooo tall. Your current gearing is even taller than stock.
Drop your tire size, you will see better acceleration in all gears. You shouldn't have to ever shift into 4th.
I'd suggest no taller than a 205/65/15. Even better would be a 205/60/15, or a 215/60/15.
Although your mph won't go up with a tire change, your ET will drop quite a bit. What's it now?